Grade:

Transfiguring Adoption awarded this movie 3 out of 5 hoots based on how helpful it will be for a foster/adoptive family. [Learn more about our Hoot grading system here]

Movie Info

• Rating: PG
• Genre: Drama
• Runtime: 109 minutes
• Studio: TriStar Pictures

From the Cover of It’s a Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood by Tristar Pictures:

Lloyd Vogel is an investigative journalist who receives an assignment to profile Fred Rogers, aka Mr. Rogers. He approaches the interview with skepticism, as he finds it hard to believe that anyone can have such a good nature. But Roger’s empathy, kindness and decency soon chips away at Vogel’s jaded outlook on life, forcing the reporter to reconcile with his own painful past.

Transfiguring Adoption’s Thoughts:

When learning that there would be a biopic about Mr. Rogers, I became very excited because I remembered growing up and watching him so much as a child. He always seemed so genuinely nice and I was afraid that this movie would be a bit boring, as I never knew of Mr. Rogers having any scandalous skeletons in his closet and was intrigued as to what the climax of the movie would be. The way the movie intertwines the characters’ lives and gives some background information helped give the characters more depth and solicited empathy from the viewer in understanding why the characters are the way they are. This movie would be a great family film watching with your children who are developmentally older than 9 as there are some events that can be triggering for younger children.

**Spoilers Could Be Ahead**

How is this Relevant to Adoption and Foster Care?

Oftentimes, when we become a caregiver to our children we have very little information to go on. We expect one thing based on the phone call from placement and overtime after learning more about their history and life experiences, we are able to understand why they have become who they are. The main character in this film, Lloyd, struggles to understand Mr. Rogers’ wholesome image and expects to find some hidden secrets which he plans to expose. Based on Lloyd’s experience with his family, he has very little faith in humanity which has shaped his world view. Many of our children have this same viewpoint as they have learned to not trust people. Family secrets come to the surface throughout the film that has impacted the way Lloyd interacts with his own family. Many times, our children will learn things about where they came from which shapes their view on themselves, their biological family, and even the motives of the family they were fostered or adopted by. Lloyd continues on his journey for closure with the help of Mr. Rogers, and as a parent the ending provides the closure we would like for our children to experience.

Discussion Points:

• Lloyd starts a fist fight with his father at a wedding
  Many of our children have experienced adults in their life physically fighting each other. Instead of being able to rely on their family to protect them, often the family is the one putting them in harm’s way. Despite the wedding being a positive affair, old wounds resurface at the worst possible time causing issues between father and son. Many of our children have memories that are tied to events that they have attended and it may be triggering for them. For example, Christmas may be considered a happy time to many but to our child they may remember arguments and fights around the holidays.
• Lloyd continues to struggle with his father abandoning his mother
  Lloyd takes his father’s abandonment of his mother very personally. It seems that by abandoning his mother, Lloyd himself feels abandoned. Many of our children may also feel abandoned by someone important in their life. Lloyd also displays the desire to be the protector of his mother and family against who he believes is a bad person: his father. Many of our children act in parentified ways towards their siblings as they feel it is their duty to protect them, as the adults responsible proved to be incapable of doing so.
• Mr. Rogers’ use of creative interviewing to get Lloyd to open up
  Mr. Rogers utilizes a method of play therapy that is often used to get children to talk. Despite Lloyd refusing to engage and shutting down, it created the ability for him to open up to Mr. Rogers in the future. This is a great thing to remember: that although we may attempt to connect with our children, they can still push us away. However, recognizing your attempt can help them feel more comfortable in the future to come to you when they feel comfortable doing so.
• Lloyd confronting his father to air his grievances
  Lloyd displayed a lot of pent up anger in his rant towards his father. Lloyd got the ability to air his grievances to his father despite the consequences of his choice not being what he was anticipating. Many of our kids have a lot of grievances to air towards previous caregivers and never get the chance to do so. Seeing Lloyd express himself (although in a poor manner) shows that old wounds can still hurt years later and that releasing that anger can be therapeutic.
• Lloyd’s reaction to his father going to the hospital
  Jerry’s subsequent heart attack, appeared to look caused by Lloyd’s rant towards him, causes Lloyd to isolate himself from his family. He refuses to stay overnight at the hospital with the rest of his family, instead choosing to leave for Pittsburgh to finish interviewing Mr. Rogers. Although Lloyd does not feel his presence at the hospital is required for his father’s sake, he fails to recognize that his presence can be incredibly helpful for his sister and his wife. Many of our children will isolate when presented with an issue as it is easier to withdraw than to deal with the situation head on. They may feel that they are not needed during an upsetting time as they may not view themselves as important to the situation.
• Lloyd dealing with the terminal illness of his mother
  Despite the anger that he has towards his father, Lloyd’s anger stems from his intense love for his mother. When Lloyd visits her in the hospital in his dream, his mother is able to see how much pain he is in by keeping the anger towards his father bottled up. His mother encourages him to forgive his father. Lloyd uses his mother’s visit in his dream as a catalyst to make amends with his father. Depending on your child they may have no recollection of their biological family, however for the ones who do, they may have recurring dreams where the family is present. This provides an opportunity to explore what meaning they were able to gain from their dream.
• Lloyd thinking about the people who “loved him into being”
  At Mr. Rogers’ prompting, Lloyd realizes that without his father, he would not have been able to have a relationship with his mother. Lloyd recognizes that he is parts of both of his parents, and that although his father made a mistake, he must have had some redeeming qualities for his mother to love him and choose him to be Lloyd’s father. Many of our children may think they are “bad” because they are a product of their biological parents, however that is simply not the case. It is important to speak highly of biological parents whenever possible because no matter what choices were made in the past, it resulted in a child we love as our own.
• Lloyd making amends
  When Lloyd is able to forgive his father, he is also inspired to make amends with his wife Andrea and vows to be a better husband and a better father. This helps showcase how holding anger and resentment can affect the way we interact with others. Oftentimes, our children have repressed feelings that affect the way they interact with their adoptive or foster families. Sometimes it feels personal, but being present and helping them hold their story can allow them to forgive and form attachments with their new family.

Cautionary Points:

• Physical fight between father and son
  If your child has been exposed to domestic violence or living in a high crime neighborhood, this scene can be triggering for our children. Being able to affirm that they are safe and physical violence will not happen to them within the new family unit can help them feel safe and secure.
• Abandonment by parent
  Seeing flashbacks of Lloyd being abandoned by his biological father can remind our children of times they felt abandoned by the people in their life who are supposed to love and protect them. Feelings of abandonment can influence how they engage in relationships, whether familial, peer, or romantic.
• Mild language such as “damn”, “what the hell”, and “holy crap”
  Oftentimes our children have heard worse language than this, however if you are very cautious of the words your children are exposed to, this should act as a cautionary point. Some children are triggered by these words as they acted as a precursor to other negative events.
• Mild alcohol references (bourbon & beer)
  Although the references of alcohol are done in a sense of offering someone a bourbon or a beer, if your children have been exposed to substance abuse it is difficult for them to differentiate between the use of alcohol acceptably and unacceptably.
• Nightmare of childhood trauma
  Seeing Lloyd have a nightmare of his childhood trauma can cause your children to remember some nightmares they have had about the trauma they experienced. Although the memories may not be completely accurate, it can still cause our children to experience anxiety and/or depression.
• Death of parents
  Lloyd experiencing his mother dying at a young age can remind the children of the parents that they have lost, whether through death, abandonment, or termination of parenting rights. Children will grieve the loss of their biological families and that is perfectly natural. Understanding the five stages of grief and how to assist your child with navigating those feelings is tremendously helpful.

Discussion Guide:

1. How do you think Lloyd could have reacted better at his sister’s wedding when we saw his dad?
Caregiver Note: Lloyd’s anger at his father for abandoning his mother was justified, but his reaction to seeing his father was inappropriate. Anger is a normal emotion but how we express it is important. This is a great way to help your children understand appropriate ways to release their anger.

2. Why do you think Lloyd struggled to trust that Mr. Rogers was as nice in person as he appeared?
Caregiver Note: Many times our children struggle to trust people because of the hurt they have experienced. Just as Lloyd struggled to believe that Mr. Rogers was a nice guy because of his childhood trauma, our children feel the same way. Helping them to verbalize this and recognize that it is not fair to judge other people based on past experiences can help your child differentiate who their anger is directed at.

3. Has there ever been someone you thought was nice who turned out to be mean?
Caregiver Note: Often when we meet someone, we meet a false version of them. Sometimes they appear nice at first but later turn out to be mean. This allows your child to talk about a teacher, a classmate, or a previous caregiver they initially thought was nice but turned out to not be nice. Explore their reasoning as to why they felt this person was mean and help them identify valid or invalid points.

4. Has there ever been someone you thought was mean and turned out to be nice? How so?
Caregiver Note: We all have bad days. If you met me on a bad day you may think I’m mean, but I know I am a genuinely nice person. Recognizing that first impressions are not always accurate can help your child build relationships in the future by providing a second chance and not relying on their first opinion.

5. What regrets do you think Lloyd has in looking back at his choices throughout this movie?
Caregiver Note: We all have regrets. Having our children identify what might be some of Lloyd’s regrets can open up the discussion about any regrets that they have. As we saw in the movie, Lloyd was able to resolve his regrets and your children are able to do that as well with your help.

6. What kind of father do you think Lloyd turned out to be?
Caregiver Note: Lloyd did not have the greatest example of being a father. He later became a father and then abandoned his family at the hospital while his dad was recovering from a heart attack. Sometimes our children have not had the best example provided to them but they now have the chance to learn appropriate skills from a parent who models them.

7. Have you ever had to ask for forgiveness? What did that feel like?
Caregiver Note: Admitting we are wrong and asking for forgiveness is hard. Helping them explore a time they had to ask for forgiveness and providing praise to them for their bravery to do so is a great bonding moment. As the parent, it would be great to also share a time that you had to ask for forgiveness as well to help establish that we all make mistakes but it is how we handle it that matters.

8. What are some ways you can forgive someone who has hurt you?
Caregiver Note: Forgiving can be hard when someone has hurt you. Use this opportunity to help point out the heaviness that Lloyd carried around before forgiving his father and expressing your desire for them to not have that same burden. Ask them if there is a way you can help.

9. What does forgiveness look like?
Caregiver Note: Everyone’s view of forgiveness is different. Some view it as simply apologizing, others prefer to see behavior change. Identifying what your child needs in order to experience forgiveness is a powerful tool to have as a parent, as it allows you to speak your child’s love language.

10. If you were to visit Mr. Rogers, what would your episode be about?
Caregiver Note: Mr. Rogers’ episodes always centered around a topic, whether friendships, death, or moving away. Allowing your child to explore the central theme of this episode with Mr. Rogers helps you understand where your child’s concerns and values are, and allows them to use their imagination. They may not have any serious topic for their episode, so use this time to engage in fun play about their episode.

[Donate to this Project]

NOTE: Inclusion on these lists does not necessarily mean endorsement. Furthermore, with all our resources, we highly recommend you preview them first to determine if there are any trauma triggers that your child may not be ready to handle. Transfiguring Adoption does not intend for its reviewers nor its reviews to be professional, medical or legal advice. These reviews and discussion guides are intended to help parents to better be able to connect and understand their children who come from traumatic backgrounds.